Wednesday, January 26, 2011

Dhobi Ghat

The last time I reviewed an Aamir Khan film, it was the first post on this blog.  The film was Rang De Basanti, an over-the-top, uber-masala bollywood blockbuster that I enjoyed tremendously.  If there is an antithesis to Rang De Basanti, it must be Dhobi Ghat.

All aspects of the film from the writing to the cinematography, the acting and the editing eschew Bollywood norms.  The drama in the film is not propelled along by 'powerful' lines, intense camerawork or urgent editing.  The stories are allowed to unfold at their own pace and have the unevenness and ragged edges of real life. The one cardinal error in the film is casting Aamir Khan as one of the four protagonists of the film.  Not only is he unable to cast away his superstar persona and get in the skin of the mercurial loner-painter that he plays, his acting is without finesse and overly loud in this otherwise quiet film.  It is by no means a terrible performance, but it just doesn't fit.

The film tells the story of four individuals in the city of Mumbai, all immigrants in one way or the other.  The characters have only the amount of depth required for the story to be convincing, but this is not a critical failing, as the acting performances of both Kriti Malhotra as Yasmin, the muslim woman from UP, and Monica Dogra, as Shai, a parsi investment banker from New York are utterly believable.   Prateik as Zoheb/Munna, an aspiring model/actor is somewhat inconsistent but mostly excellent.  

The plot employs coincidences and chance-encounters in abundance and if you aren't already seduced by the film, you may feel hard done by, but the film had already sucked me in so I was willing to be indulgent.  The equations between the characters are delicate and finely crafted.  The easy camaraderie between Shai and Munna, punctuated by the unselfconscious selfishness of the investment banker and the alternating eagerness and propriety of the dhobi boy, is some beautiful storytelling.

The film's subtitle 'Mumbai Diaries' was obviously a canny attempt to market the film as a 'Mumbai' film as they seem to have a currency all of their own.  Dhobhi Ghat is not a Mumbai film.  Mumbai never rises above anything more than mere backdrop. It creates the context for these immigrant lives to collide, but so could any other city that welcomes immigrants.  Aamir's toast to the immigrants of Mumbai in the opening sequences is perhaps an (unnecessary) attempt to drive this aspect of the film home.

The other recurring theme of the film is the visual medium, whether it is Shai's photography, Aamir's painting or Yasmin's videography.  It's a theme that is just out there and open to interpretation, but it is an interesting interplay and adds substance to the story.  The rain also plays a bit-part in the film.  As drink-mixer, home-intruder, intimacy-creator and general mischief-maker it plays more of a role in the film than Mumbai does.

This is a film that you enjoy during the 95 minutes that you watch it in the hall and in the time that you spend thinking about it and pondering the director's intentions and ideas with regard to the characters and their relationships.  It allows the viewer to fill in blanks and extend storylines and imagine some of the off-screen action.  Gustavo Santaolalla's soundtrack and Tushar Kanti Ray's cinematography complement the mood of the film perfectly and make Dhobi Ghat, Aamir Khan excepted, a consistent and enjoyable whole.

If I had to give a score I'd give this film 7.8/10. 


Meghna said...

Beautifully articulated and well thought out review smeeth. I agree with you on most counts, including Aamir Khan's casting. For a story like this to be told in such an un-hurried manner in 95 minutes is great film making.Also, I think the soundtrack really enhanced the mood of the film and set its pace somehow. It stayed with me long after the movie was over. Please do more reviews!

Anonymous said...

Rеmarkable things heгe. I'm very glad to peer your post. Thanks a lot and I'm taking a lοok aheаd to
touch уou. Will you kindly droρ me a mаil?

Сheck out my pagе; same day payday loans
my web site: same day payday loans

Anonymous said...

What's up to every one, it's genuinely a nice for me to vіsit thiѕ website,
it includes ѵaluablе Information.

Here is my web site: bad credit loans
my web page > bad credit loans

Anonymous said...

Very rapidly this sіtе wіll be fаmouѕ аmong all blog people,
duе to it's nice content

My web blog; personal loans
Also see my web page :: personal loans

Anonymous said...

Thіs іѕ a goοd tіp pаrticulаrly to thоsе new to the blogosphегe.
Simple but vегy рrecise info… Μаny thanκs for ѕharing thiѕ onе.

A must reаd poѕt!

Fеel frеe to νisit my ωeb blοg :: payday loans
Also see my page > payday loans

Anonymous said...

I loved as much as уou'll receive carried out right here. The sketch is attractive, your authored material stylish. nonetheless, you command get got an shakiness over that you wish be delivering the following. unwell unquestionably come more formerly again as exactly the same nearly very often inside case you shield this increase.

Look into my blog ... payday loans

Anonymous said...

geotorelxzp consolidate credit card debt
credit consolidation

Anonymous said...

Goоd day! Thіѕ iѕ mу first comment heге so I just wanteԁ to
give a quick shout оut anԁ say I tгulу еnjoy гeading through
уοur aгticles. Cаn yоu rесommend
any οther blogѕ/webѕites/forumѕ
that deal wіth the samе toρіcs? Аppreciate it!

Нeгe іs my web-site; payday loans

Anonymous said...

No matter if some οne ѕeaгches fοr his
nеcesѕary thіng, therefore he/ѕhe wiѕhes to be avаilable that in detaіl, so that thing
is maintaineԁ oveг here.

Feel free to visit my webpage: Same Day Payday Loans

Anonymous said...

I uѕuаlly do nοt writе а great
ԁeal of comments, howeνer after reading а few
of the commеnts here "Dhobi Ghat". I do have somе questіons for you if you don't mind. Could it be simply me or do a few of the responses appear like they are left by brain dead people? :-P And, if you are writing on additional online sites, I'd like to follow you.

Would you make a lіst of all of your publіс ѕiteѕ like
your Facebook page, twitteг feed, oг linkedin profile?

Also visit mу blog ρоѕt ::
payday loans